Discussions started by Paul Stacey

Hi all. As you know from discussions and plans today is the OERU face-to-face meeting happening in New Zealand. For instructions around virtual participation see:
http://wikieducator.org/OER_for_Assessment_and_Credit_for_Students/Virtual_participation

This SCoPE seminar has been planned to stimulate discussion in advance of todays meeting and to provide a forum for follow-on discussion after today's meeting. I promised Wayne I'd provide a short summary of our discussions and drop-in think tank web conference as an input into today's face to face meeting.

Here's what I submitted:

OER University - A Summary of SCoPE Seminar Inputs

The following notes are summarized from SCoPE OERu online discussions and an OERu drop-in think tank web conference session held over the period 4-21-Feb-2011. The summary has been distilled from contributions made by participants from Israel, United States, New Zealand, India, Canada, Netherlands, Australia, United Kingdom, Pakistan, Portugal, and Brazil.

OER University Model and Ideas

The OERu:
  • is a a consortium of partner universities - a university of universities. Participating colleges/universities are given an OERu logo to post on their web-sites designating them as participants.
  • un-bundles the package of services traditional universities provide: recommending (and selling) learning materials, forming learning groups, arranging learning experiences, supplying teachers, certifying
  • provides a search service for OER materials and maintains a repository of credit based OER approved by the consortium
  • brings together currently separate OER initiatives to generate collaboration between them for development and assemblage of OER into mutually credentialed outcomes.
  • creates a framework within which existing OER can be assembled and new OER development positioned.
  • establishes a world OER credit bank and trans-national qualifications framework. Institutions developing OER can register their OER with the credit bank specifying what credit they are willing to accord those who successfully complete the learning outcomes associated with it. OERu assembles or creates the transfer/articulation aspects of assembling OER into a credential. Each OERu university partner can link existing OER courses of other partner universities to its OER degree programmes
  • facilitates creation of an OER learning path, learning plan, and/or PLAR documentation template for students ideally through consultation with advisor or mentor
  • helps learners systematically pursue learning plan and create a portfolio that can be assessed
  • provides student support resources to help students navigate their learning paths and compile portfolios. Partners with institutions who provide options for student support possibly on a fee for service basis. A 24x7 call center for assisting students.
  • creates a social learning context for OER reinserting or applying pedagogy to OER. Utilizes mass collaboration approaches combined with social networking to establish peer-to-peer and tutor-student support potentially with senior students receiving credit for tutoring juniour students. Provides a brokering/marketplace where those who want to facilitate learning can meet those who want to learn. Emphasizes peer-to-peer social learning over teacher/student traditional learning. Students as teachers solidifies learning.
  • prioritizes low-cost / low-bandwidth solutions for learner support and uses mobile technologies for these interactive components
  • provides continuous entry points throughout the year with entry by exams rather than prerequisite courses or degrees. A 365 days online registration and evaluation process.
  • supports individual pace of learning, multiple exit points, including instant certification by testing
  • removes affiliation requirements, residency or citizenship requirements, age restrictions (make OERu undergraduate and graduate programs open to children)
  • provides certification or links to colleges and universities who do a PLAR like assessment of the portfolio
  • ­awards the degree with logos of universities who participated in the validation process displayed on the certificate or alternatively the universities themselves confer the credentials
  • maintains a registry of graduates

OERu Users and Use Cases
  • a student using OER could literally study anywhere in the world for free and transfer his/her learning to a "receiving institution" for conversion to transfer credit
  • personally designed pick and choose model where students formulate their own learning pathway (likely favoured by working professionals)
  • structured degree model where templates of predefined OER are assembled into a curriculum leading to a credential (younger students looking for qualifications to move into professional area in labour market)
  • OER-U could also work in K-12 sector to establish elementary and secondary programs leading to post-secondary so someone could presumably begin at the primary/elementary level and progress seemlessly to undergraduate or even graduate degrees

OERu Questions & Challenges

How to develop the course materials for learners globally?

Providing not only free education but free authentic, valid and reliable certification too. Leaners may need to pay for credential services unless national governments provide grants to cover these costs through the state education system.

Finding a free online platform or specifying that learning materials for the OER university be developed (or converted) into open file formats that are equally accessible by a variety of Learning Management Systems (LMSs).

OER have to be available or at least readily convertible to low tech, pencil and paper, or print-based materials.

Institutions will not move toward an OERu strategy unless they see a clear benefit for themselves. Does OERu need to be a parallel higher education universe?

Develop low-overhead quality and accreditation systems building an entirely new model rather than adapting the old one.

The concept of an OER-university is an innovation and a major one for the education globally. Individual and organisational adoption will depend on the current concerns and benefits of this innovation for them.

Be more creative. Start without thinking about existing systems and courses. Rethink units of learning.

OERu needs to be younger and bolder. We need to get our heads into being 15 to 25 again.

We already have a critical mass to at least get one degree operational.

This summary is available for the New Zealand participants and anyone else as a .pdf download in the OERU Meeting Agenda.

Its always a challenge to distill and coalesce the rich discussions we've been having but I'm hoping you all find this a reasonable representation. Thank you all for your insights and suggestions, I think this summary is a great start to defining an OERU. Feel free to post a reply here with anything you'd like to add. I'll be briefing the New Zealand participants on our activities and this summary via phone later today.

Paul
This seminar is being held in support of the OER University meeting taking place in New Zealand next week. One of the key objectives for that meeting is to "Develop a shared understanding of a logic model for the OER university concept." This objective is crucial.

We launched this SCoPE seminar a few days early with the OER Challenge which explores some of the underlying logic of an OER university by engaging you in the use of OER to fulfill your own personal learning objectives. There are some great responses to the OER Challenge already underway in that discussion thread and I invite you all to join in.

Today is the official launch of the OER University SCoPE seminar and I'd like to focus in on the OER University logic model explicitly with this discussion thread and with a live Elluminate web conference session Friday Feb 18, 2011 at 1:30 pm PST. Information about the web conference session will be posted separately on the SCoPE OER University forum page.

The OER University section of the Wikieducator site has several resources exploring the logic model. You can go there and explore them in more detail but for our purposes I've pasted the high level logic model diagram and OER university concept diagram here into this post.
550px-OERU-logic-model.png
High Level Logic Model


550px-OER-University-concept.png
OER University Concept


The overall aim of the OER university intervention is to:
  • develop and implement a sustainable and scalable ecosystem which provides free learning opportunities for all students worldwide using OER
  • ensure pathways for OER learners to obtain credible certification and qualifications within national education systems.

So lets get some discussion underway on this logic.

What questions do you have about the OER university concept or high level logic model?

Here are just a couple of mine:
  • Should the OER University be an actual entity/institution or is it better for it to simply be a framework or designation that institutions can adopt should they choose to participate?
  • Do students formulate their own learning pathway based on available OER or do institutions identify a curriculum of OER and formulate credentials they are willing to provide for completion of that curriculum?

Feel free to post questions, suggest answers, or just comment overall about the logic model or concept.

Paul

SCoPE: Seminars -> OER university: Feb 16-Mar 2, 2011 -> What's OER?

by Paul Stacey -
Today I got an e-mail from someone saying "this [the OER Challenge] sounds like fun and very interesting. However, I've got a prob- what's OER?"

Great to get this question right at the start of this seminar. OER stands for Open Educational Resources. OER are learning materials that are freely available under a license that allows them to be:
  • reused - you have the right to reuse the content in its unaltered / verbatim form
  • revised - you have the right to adapt, adjust, modify, or alter the content itself
  • remixed - you have the right to combine the original or revised content with other content to create something new
  • redistributed - you have the right to make and share copies of the original content, your revisions, or your remixes with others

Implementation involves licenses, tools (store, search distribute, …), processes (design, development, …) and resulting content (full courses, modules, learning objects, media elements, …)

Over the past 5 years Open Educational Resources have flourished and expanded into an international movement. There are many examples of Open Educational Resource initiatives around the world.

My short list of popular OER initiatives includes:
and many more.

David Wiley’s recent Open Education Resource webcast for Educause provides a good introduction to what OER are all about. You can see the recording of this presentation at: http://educause.adobeconnect.com/p55443669/

Numerous portals that aggregate and list OER available for reuse also exist including:

The Open Education Resource Foundation this seminar is working in partnership with provides a forum for networking together OER initiatives from around the world.

A large range of books and journal articles have been written on OER.
The OECD Centre for Educational Research and Innovation has numerous Open Educational Resource publications including:
  1. Giving Knowledge for Free: The Emergence of Open Educational Resources
  2. On the Sustainability of OER initiatives
  3. Open Educational Resources, Open Content Licensing
All these and more are available from the OECD website at: http://www.oecd.org/document/20/0,2340,en_2649_34859749_35023444_1_1_1_1,00.html.

The book Opening Up Education: The Collective Advancement of Education through Open Technology, Open Content, and Open Knowledge edited by T. Iiyoshi & M. S. V. Kumar (2008) provides extensive background and case studies.

UNESCO has an Open Educational Resources site including case study stories http://oerwiki.iiep-unesco.org/index.php?title=Main_Page

The July/August 2010 issue of Educause covers the entire field of “open” in education. See:
http://www.educause.edu/EDUCAUSE%2BReview/ERVolume442009/EDUCAUSEReviewMagazineVolume45/209245

"Free to Learn: an Open Educational Resources Policy Development Guidebook for Community College Governance Officials" by Hal Plotkin was just published using a Creative Commons license in October 2010 and is available online for free at: http://wiki.creativecommons.org/Free_to_Learn_Guide

For those new to OER I hope the above provides a mini orientation.

Given the world wide interest in the upcoming OER University events I thought I'd define an early activity and invite you all to start right away.

Take the OER Challenge

The OER Challenge is a dare to all of you that tests out the ideas behind the OER University.

The OER challenge is a three step dare:

Step 1. Identify a set of learning objectives you personally want to achieve.
  • These can be formal or informal.
  • You can find and pursue learning objectives that are part of formal academic offering.
  • You can identify informal personal learning objectives that are an area of interest you'd like to know more about or skill you'd like to acquire.
  • Reply to this OER Challenge post with your objectives in point form.

Step 2. Find OER that help you meet those learning objectives.
  • Pair the OER you find with the learning objectives you identified in step 1.
  • Try and find OER that not only includes content relevant to your learning objectives but learning activities too.
  • Reply to your Step 1 OER challenge post with a follow-on posts or series of posts identifying OER related to your learning objectives.

Step 3. Identify who you'd like to have as your OER credentialing agent.
  • Who is qualified to assess you to ensure the learning has occurred?
  • Who would you like to see as the entity that publicly states that you have achieved those learning objectives?

That's it.
Easy as 1, 2, 3!

If you decide not to personally take the OER Challenge I encourage you to help those who are by assisting them in finding OER related to their objectives and/or suggesting credentialing agents.

Paul

To support knowledge mobilization, communication, interaction and peer sharing of expertise and practices associated with teaching, learning and research, BCcampus has established a network of online communities. Online communities are different from standard websites in that they provide a means for grassroots communication and collaboration among peers through self-service posting of resources, requests and advice.

Its an honour to have the Learn Together Collaboratory featured as the first case study in this three week long seminar. On Monday during the live opening session I'll share some context on how BCcampus came to develop a network of communities, how we support them, and some of the challenges we face moving forward. Andrew Marchand will present more specifically on the Learn Together Collaboratory and his work developing the functionality of that community space. Feel free to check the space out in advance at http://ltcollaboratory.org. Look forward to engaging with all of you on this topic and hearing your observations, recommendations, and own personal experiences.

Paul