Ethical Framework Examples from Instructors

NOTE: Developing an ethical framework for AI image generation is a personal endeavour. Some may prefer a series of questions to ask themselves before or during the process, while others may opt for a single statement, a checklist, or even an acronym. The key is to create a framework that aligns with your individual approach.

Brent's Ethical Framework for using AI image generation:

Here is an example of my framework, which I consider a tool – a guideline or living document that I can modify as needed. As conditions change or my workflow evolves, I can update my framework to reflect those new factors.

1. Purpose: Why am I using AI instead of other tools?
2. Originality: Am I using the style and technique of a living artist?
3. Impact: Could this tool lead to more stereotypical or colonial images that might harm others?
4. Message: What do I aim to communicate?
5. Stakes: What are the consequences of this project?
6. Audience: Who will view this image?

Here is what I am thinking about with each question:

1. Purpose: Why am I using AI instead of other tools?

• Is speed a critical factor?
• Am I trying to create a technique I don't possess?
• Could I use a licensed image, take a photo with my phone, or do I lack a clear understanding of the subject?

2. Originality: Am I using the style and technique of a living artist?

• I don't want to rely on someone else's creation to lend credibility to my work.
• I believe artists should have control over how their art is used.

3. Impact: Could this tool lead to more stereotypical or colonial images that might harm others?

• Am I creating content that appropriates icons and images from another group?
• Am I reinforcing colonial ideas and stereotypes?

4. Message: What do I aim to communicate?

• Why am I creating this image?
• What is the intended message behind it?

5. Stakes: What are the consequences of this project?

• Is this image for a one-time use, like a PowerPoint presentation for a small meeting?
• Is this image a permanent representation of my business, like a logo?
• Is this image something I want to include in a published book?

6. Audience: Who will view this image?

• What does my audience expect?
• What will resonate best with them?