Pamela:
Your comments have got me thinking.
Initially, and despite the title of the seminar, I was thinking in terms of personal (vs. professional) learning and so any evaluation would be personal and probably subjective.
Teachers often see evidence of informal learning in the questions learners ask, the reflections and observations in their written responses, and the nature of their musings in discussion groups (in-class and on-line).
Certainly, the broader knowledge of the learner is picked up in the formal evaluations (of assignments). I wonder if informal learning is "informally" evaluated in the professionalism component of a course. If so, I also wonder about, and worry about, the subjective nature of such a mark.
For now, I can see the value of capturing informal learning (perhaps through journaling/blogging), but I'm wondering if we should be trying to evaluate informal learning if it has a grade attached to it.
Cheers, Chris Horgan