Tara,
Your concept of evaluating the student's feedback when giving peer feedback is intriguing. Will you give them a rubric to base their feedback on? It's like reflecting on your reflections.
Just checking to make sure I understand your design.
Your have four weighted criteria: relevance = 1, examples = 1, detail = 5, and overall impression = 3 for a total of 10 marks for each of the five student-assessed criteria. Do you provide a score for each of the five student-assessed criteria? For example, would you give each of the five student-assessed criteria a score of 1 or 0 for the relevance and examples criteria, from 0 to 5 for the detail criteria, and from 0 to 3 for the overall impression criteria? . If so, then you would end up with a possible total score of 5 for relevance, 5 for examples, 25 for details, and 15 for overall impression for a total of 50 marks. Then, all you have to do with your total mark is to convert it to a % by multiplying by 2.
Or have I misread your rubric, and you only give one score of 3 at the end for overall impression criteria, which would result in total score of 5 + 5 + 25 +3 = 38, not so easy to convert to a %?
Out of confusion comes clarity.
Leonne